Bay Rum
Bay Rum by Stirling Soap Co. is built around cinnamon, clove and nutmeg, joined by orange, West Indian bay and bay rum. It is part of the Bay Rum family. The scent comes as an aftershave splash, an aftershave balm, a solid cologne and an eau de toilette.
Scent profile
Fragrance notes describe scent impressions and are not an ingredient list. Missing information does not confirm that an ingredient is absent.
Products with this scent
Sizes of a product count once| Product | Sizes | Base |
|---|---|---|
 Shaving soap |
Tallow Croap Shaving Soap | |
 Aftershave splash |
Alcohol Aftershave Splash | |
| Aftershave splash |
Alcohol-Free Aftershave Splash | |
 Aftershave balm |
Aftershave Balm | |
 Eau de toilette |
Not documented | |
 Solid cologne |
Solid Cologne |
Similar scents
Compared by the notes the makers list – distinctive notes count more than subtle ones, rare notes more than common ones. A pointer, not a promise that they smell alike.
-
Ethos Grooming Essentials
Bay RumSimilarity: almost the same notesShared: West Indian bay, bay rum accord and clove
shaving soap · eau de toilette
-
Clubman PinaudBay RumSimilarity: very similar
Shared: bay rum accord, West Indian bay and clove
aftershave splash · eau de cologne
-
Nomad Theory
SpicySimilarity: very similarShared: West Indian bay, bay rum accord and clove · plus black pepper
shaving soap · aftershave splash · aftershave balm
-
Black Ship GroomingBay RumSimilarity: very similar
Shared: West Indian bay and bay rum accord
aftershave splash
-
Phoenix Artisan AccoutrementsBay RumSimilarity: very similar
Shared: West Indian bay and bay rum accord · plus smoke and coconut
shaving soap · aftershave splash · eau de parfum · solid cologne
-
Bay Rum OgallalaBay RumSimilarity: very similar
Shared: bay rum accord and West Indian bay · plus sage and barbershop accord
shaving soap · aftershave splash
Questions about Bay Rum
- Who makes Bay Rum?
- Bay Rum is a scent by Stirling Soap Co., a maker from the United States.
- What does Bay Rum by Stirling Soap Co. smell like?
-
According to the maker’s descriptions in ShaveIndex:
- Scent family: Bay Rum
- Notes: Bay Rum, Cinnamon, Clove, Nutmeg, Orange, West Indian Bay
- Which products are available in the scent Bay Rum?
-
ShaveIndex lists 6 products in this scent:
- Bay Rum Shaving Soap
- Bay Rum Aftershave Splash
- Bay Rum Witch Hazel & Aloe
- Bay Rum Aftershave Balm
- Bay Rum Eau de Toilette
- Bay Rum Solid Cologne
- What are the Bay Rum products made of?
-
According to the ingredient lists in ShaveIndex:
- Aftershave Balm – Cream or balm; coconut oil, grapeseed oil, meadowfoam oil, shea butter, stearic acid; No alcohol listed; No animal ingredient listed
- Alcohol Aftershave Splash – Liquid; Alcohol listed; No animal ingredient listed
- Alcohol-Free Aftershave Splash – Liquid; No alcohol listed; No animal ingredient listed
- Solid Cologne – Solid, wax-based; beeswax, candelilla wax, coconut oil, grapeseed oil, shea butter; No alcohol listed; Animal ingredient listed
- Tallow Croap Shaving Soap – Croap (hard and soft); almond oil, beef tallow, castor oil, lanolin, shea butter, stearic acid; No alcohol listed; Animal ingredient listed
- Do the Bay Rum products have a cooling effect?
-
Cooling as recorded in ShaveIndex (products without a value are not listed):
- All 5 products with a value: No cooling
- Which scents are similar to Bay Rum?
- Close in scent according to the ShaveIndex scent analysis: Bay Rum (Ethos Grooming Essentials) (Ethos Grooming Essentials), Virgin Island Bay Rum (Clubman Pinaud) and Magens Bay (Nomad Theory). This is a comparison of the recorded notes, not a promise.
Member ratings
No ratings yet.
Ratings reflect members’ personal experiences. Each rating is reviewed before it appears; there is no overall score.